top of page
Search

The Most Important Thing You Can Say Is Nothing

Nov 5
5 min read

William Ury is one of the world's most influential experts on negotiation. He has quite literally written the book on the subject. As the co-author of the bestselling Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In, Ury has spent decades helping people and nations find common ground, from labor disputes to international conflicts and civil wars.


His work has taken him from helping establish U.S.-Soviet nuclear risk reduction centers during the Cold War to advising former Colombian President Juan Manuel Santos during the peace negotiations with the FARC guerrillas. He has seen firsthand what happens when people who disagree deeply try to find a way forward.


And yet, one of his most fascinating observations has almost nothing to do with what people say.


In research examining hundreds of negotiations, Ury and his colleagues studied the pauses that occurred during conversations and looked for patterns that might predict successful outcomes. What they discovered was fascinating. There was an unmistakable correlation between the amount of silence in a negotiation and the likelihood of reaching a positive agreement.


In other words, the people who were most successful at negotiating weren't necessarily the ones who talked the most, made the strongest arguments, or had the most persuasive responses. They were the ones who knew when to stop talking.


Why? Because silence creates the space to listen, to process what the other person is actually saying, and to understand what is really driving the other person’s position.


Think about what usually happens in any disagreement. While someone else is talking, we are not really listening. Instead, we are thinking about what we are going to say next, how we will counter their argument, or how we will make our point more convincingly. We may be hearing every word, but our minds are already somewhere else.


Ury’s insight is that the most constructive thing you can do in that moment is resist the urge to speak and not rush to speak. Instead, give the other person the opportunity to finish and then give yourself the opportunity to think.


The goal of a negotiation isn’t to always win every argument. It’s to understand enough to find a solution and you cannot do that if you are too busy talking. And so, the secret to being a better communicator, is actually learning to say less and listen more.


These past few weeks, I have been thinking a lot about the power of silence. I recently lost my voice and have been struggling to regain it fully. I was been instructed to talk as little as possible, something that I found incredibly difficult. As someone who speaks and teaches for a living, this has been particularly challenging.


We don't always realize how much of our day is spent talking, responding, explaining, and offering our opinions. But when you are forced to speak less, you begin to notice that there is so much more to hear.


The Yerushalmi teaches this idea through the famous story of Shlomo HaMelech and the two women who each claimed to be the mother of the same baby. When the women appeared before the king, each insisted that the living child belonged to her and that the other woman's child had died.


Before rendering his judgment, Shlomo did something seemingly unnecessary. He carefully repeated both women's arguments.


"The one says, 'This is my son, the living one, and the dead one is yours'; and the other says, 'No, the dead one is yours, and the living one is mine.'"


Why did Shlomo need to repeat what both women had just said? He was the wisest man in the world. Surely he understood their claims. The Yerushalmi offers a remarkable insight. Shlomo wanted each woman to know that she had been heard. Before deciding the case, he made sure that both women felt that their words had been received and understood. He understood that leadership is not just about having the wisdom to make the right decision. It is also about making people feel that their voices matter. Before you can resolve someone's problem, you need to demonstrate that you have taken the time to understand it.


And that is true in our own lives as well. Sometimes people don't need us to solve their problems and they don't need another piece of advice, a clever response, or an explanation of why they are wrong. They need to know that someone cares enough to listen.


A few years ago, Rabbi Reuven Leuchter shared a powerful story in Mishpacha Magazine. He related that his adult son once told him something that stopped him in his tracks:


"Do you know why I stayed frum over the years? Because for as long as I can remember, you were always interested in what I had to say."


A father might assume that his influence came from the Torah he taught, the values he modeled, or the guidance he offered. And certainly, all of those things matter. But his son identified something else entirely, his father had always been interested in listening to him.

That is an extraordinary legacy. Listening communicates something that words often cannot. It says, “you matter, what you think matters, and what you feel matters. I am interested in you, not just in what I want to tell you.”


We sometimes think that being a good parent means having the right answers, that being a good spouse means knowing how to fix a problem, or that being a good friend means offering the right advice. But perhaps one of the greatest gifts we can give the people we love is the willingness to put our own thoughts aside long enough to hear theirs.


Listening is one of the simplest and most overlooked forms of kindness. It costs us nothing, yet it can strengthen a marriage, deepen a friendship, help a child feel valued, and give someone who is struggling the reassurance that they are not alone.


It also makes us better people. When we truly listen, we become less convinced that we already know everything. We become more open to other perspectives, more willing to reconsider our assumptions, and more capable of understanding people whose experiences are different from our own.


It is why Hashem created us with two ears and one mouth so that we would listen twice as much as we speak.


Losing my voice was certainly challenging. I look forward to speaking, teaching, and doing all the things I have always done. But perhaps this experience has offered me a lesson I needed to hear. We spend so much of our lives trying to find the right words. We want to be persuasive, articulate, insightful, and interesting and we want people to hear what we have to say.


But maybe we should spend a little more time thinking about whether we are giving others that same opportunity.


William Ury's research suggests that silence can be the key to reaching an agreement. Shlomo HaMelech understood that people need to feel heard before they can accept a decision. And one father discovered that his willingness to listen helped shape his son's entire Jewish journey.


Sometimes the most meaningful thing we can say to another person is nothing at all. We just need to listen.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page